About SCAP
The Chairs and Members of the Panel
The Act states that Scottish Ministers must appoint a number of people to serve as members of SCAP.
Following open competition, Scottish Ministers have appointed a pool of 8 chairs and 16 members assessed as meeting the required criteria and demonstrating the competences required for appointment. Appointments are for a period of four years with effect from 1 October 2006.
A Panel will comprise a chair, who must be a qualified solicitor, and two members. Selection of a chair and Panel members to address specific appeals will be on a rota basis taking into account availability, geographical proximity and potential conflicts of interest.
The Panel may consider appeals in the circumstances set out in Section 76 of the Act. The panel will consider the appeal in line with the appeal procedures set out in the SCAP Rules of Procedure.
The Panel is independent of Ministers but is accountable to them. The chairs and members of the panel must abide by the principles of collective responsibility and are expected to conduct themselves in a manner befitting public office. They must also identify in a register of members’ interests certain interests to ensure that no conflicts arise between their outside interests and their appointment or any particular case.
SCAP Members
CHAIR
Saria Akhter, Solicitor
Glasgow
Aileen Devanny, Solicitor
Motherwell
Joseph Hughes, Solicitor Advocate
Bothwell
Jackie McGuire, Solicitor
Aberuthven
Gary McIlravey, Solicitor
Dundee
Norman Phillips, Solicitor
Inverness
John Walker, Solicitor
Ayr
William Wood, Solicitor
Stirling
MEMBER
Cllr Jeremy Balfour, Minister of Religion
Edinburgh
Lesley Clare, Tribunal Member
Gullane
Neil Dickson, Senior University Teacher
Kelso
George Finlayson, Retired Diplomat
Edinburgh
Cllr Lawrence Fitzpatrick, Chartered Secretary
Livingston
Asif Haseeb, Senior Manager, Audit Scotland
Glasgow
Corryne Maclean, Development Manager
Newmills, Fife
Robert Mayes, Retired Banker
Falkirk
Mary McKenna, Social Worker
Edinburgh
Catriona McPhee-Smith, Chief Executive, Inspire Ltd
Aberdeen
Nicholas Morris, Retired
Cupar
Patricia Paton, Retired
Dundee
Mary Paulson-Ellis, Project Worker
Edinburgh
Jenny Simpson, Chartered Accountant
Glasgow
Michael Watters, Judge
Glasgow
Catriona Whitfield, Chartered Accountant
Helmsdale
